She’s the first to disappear—and for good reason.
Skip to product information
Buckeye
$3.50 USD
Buckeye
Peanut butter. Chocolate shell. The holiday role model.
Inspired by the simple little cookie-ball everyone fights over at Christmas swaps, our Buckeye is pure nostalgia: a smooth peanut butter center dipped in rich chocolate for that iconic two-tone bite. Limited quantities, guaranteed to disappear fast—because this one is a number one favorite.
Why You’ll Love It
- Creamy peanut butter dough that melts in your mouth
- Chocolate coating that delivers the perfect PB/Chocolate balance
-
That “I’ll just take one more” energy all season long
Perfect For:
- Holiday cookie trays and swaps
- Peanut butter + chocolate superfans
-
Anyone who knows the best cookies are the simplest
Contains: wheat, eggs, dairy. Baked near tree nuts.